Round 108: 7F24 vs. 8F20.
7F24: “Stark Raving Dad” (Season 3 / September 19, 1991)
Written by Al Jean & Mike Reiss
Directed by Rich Moore
Showrunners: James L. Brooks, Matt Groening, Sam Simon
Such an odd and quirky and wonderful episode. Having Michael Jackson as a guest star could have so easily been nothing more than an empty cameo, a gimmicky publicity stunt. Instead, he actually gets to act as a genuine character who is bridging the A plot of Lisa feeling sad and alone on her birthday to the B storyline of Homer, through equal faults Bart’s and his own, being committed to a mental hospital.
“Stark Raving Dad” came at the very tail end of the Brooks/Groening/Simon tenure, and it shows how much the show has grown in just two years, both in style – the beautiful animation by Rich Moore – and content – a brilliant, funny, and emotionally rich script by showrunners-to-be Jean and Reiss.
- -Homer: “Pink?! Marge, I can’t wear a pink shirt to work. Everybody wears white shirts. I’m not popular enough to be different.”
8F20: “Black Widower” (Season 3 /April 9, 1992)
Written by Jon Vitti and Sam Simon & Thomas Chastain
Directed by David Silverman
Showrunners: Al Jean & Mike Reiss
Sideshow Bob is always fun. I like that there are clues throughout the episode as to his murderous scheme, so the attentive viewer can actually solve the case as it unfolds. And, being directed by David Silverman, of course we are treated gorgeous, cinematic visuals.
But, while I liked “Black Widower,” I enjoyed the other episode even more. So:
The winner: 7F24, “Stark Raving Dad.”